The Unsolved Murder of Arnold Schuster
 
The Goodfella
Murder of Arnold Schuster
Capture of Willie Sutton
 
The FBI's Most Wanted
Willie Sutton
Frederick Tenuto
 
The Mafia Connection
Albert Anastasia
The Valachi Hearings
 
Arnold Schuster.com
About Us
Make A Donation
Contact Us
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
"The murder outraged the city of New York, There were calls for a crackdown on the mob. The Schuster murder went against one of the Mafia's own cardinal rules: Kill only for good reason; never kill out of caprice" - Mafia Dynasty: The Rise and Fall of the Gambino Crime Family
 
Arnold Schuster The Unsolved Murder of Arnold Schuster
Arnold Schuster was a Brooklyn clothing salesman and amateur detective, known for his involvement in the capture of the notorious bank robber Willie "The Actor" Sutton and for subsequently being the victim of a gangland murder by the Gambino crime family. Arnold Schuster was murdered outside of his home on March 8th, 1952. He was shot twice in the groin and once in each eye. Read more about the murder of Arnold Schuster
   
Willie Sutton The Capture of Bank Robber Willie "The Actor" Sutton
Willie Sutton was a notorious thief and bank robber. During his forty year criminal career he stole an estimated $2 million dollars, and eventually spent more than half of his adult life in prison. For his style of executing robberies in disguises, he gained two nicknames, "Willie the Actor" and "Slick Willie." In February 1952, Sutton was captured by police after having been recognized on a subway and followed by Arnold Schuster. Read Willie's own testimony on how Schuster captured him
   
Frederick Tenuto Frederick Tenuto The Angel of Death. FBI Most Wanted
Frederick Tenuto was a career criminal believed by many to be the man that murdered Arnold Schuster. He escaped from prison in 1947 and appeared on the FBI's most wanted list. After the death of Arnold Schuster he was never seen nor heard from again. According to Joseph Valachi's testimony Tenuto was murdered by Albert Anastasia to keep him silent and to remove any ties to the ordered murder of Arnold Schuster. Read more about Frederick Tenuto
   
Joseph Valachi The Valachi Hearings. Did The Mafia order the Murder of Arnold Schuster?
The Valachi Hearings, or also commonly known as the McClellan Hearings, investigated organized crime activities.The first American Mafia government witness, Joseph Valachi appeared before the subcommittee in 1962 and gave the American public a firsthand account of Mafia activities in the United States and Canada. Read Joseph Valachi's testimony on who was responsible for the murder of Arnold Schuster.
   
Historical Records Historical Records on the Arnold Schuster Murder Case
The historical records section of the web site contains newspaper clippings, magazine articles and books about the Arnold Schuster murder. Coming soon
   
 
 
ArnoldSchuster.com is a web site memorial dedicated to the unsolved murder of Arnold Schuster. We are not affiliated with the Schuster family or any law enforcement agencies. The purpose of this web site is to create an accurate historical record and to educate the general public of this viscious crime.